• Today’s Topics:
  • THE STORE
  • Helen Twelvetrees Bio
    • Or Head to Amazon to buy my Helen Twelvetrees book
  • Head to WarrenWilliam.com
  • Cliff’s Fiction
  • Blog

Immortal Ephemera

Classic Movies & Movie Collectibles

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Privacy Policy
  • Reviews
    • Pre-Code
    • Horror
    • Gangsters
    • Warner Archive
  • Biographies
  • Card & Collectible Galleries
    • About Movie Collectibles
    • My eBay Store
    • My Books
    • Glossary
    • eBay Shopping Tips
  • Info / Misc
    • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • My Bookshelf
    • Movie Books
    • WAMPAS
  • Social
    • Contact
    • YouTube
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
You are here: Home / News - Notes / Did Clark Gable Kill the Undershirt?

Did Clark Gable Kill the Undershirt?

August 26, 2013 By Cliff Aliperti 29 Comments

Helen Twelvetrees, Pefect Ingenue by Cliff Aliperti
Support the site? Skip buying me a coffee and grab yourself some movie cards & collectibles instead! Shop my eBay store here.


The Walls of Jericho are up and Clark Gable begins undressing.

Off comes his sweater …

Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert

… his tie …

Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert

… his shirt and, what, no undershirt!?

Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert

An industry dies.

Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert

That’s what they say at least.

Now had he worn an undershirt Gable wouldn’t have been wearing what I think of as an undershirt, the modern T-shirt, but would have had on one of those old time undershirts with the thin shoulder straps, more closely resembling the present-day tank top.

They had come into vogue during World War I, replacing the then standard one-piece union suit of underwear. That change is typically attributed to comfort, or rather discomfort. Either the union suit just didn’t feel right under a uniform or the single piece of underwear made it tougher to get at the louses that infiltrated the trenches.

After Gable killed the undershirt in It Happened One Night the underwear industry supposedly went into an uproar as sales plummeted, not to recover until World War II ushered in the modern T-shirt.

That’s the legend. Look, I can document Gable’s hand in all of this:

Sales drop 40% thanks to Gable in It Happened One Night according to this article found in the April 3, 1956 edition of the Daytona Beach Morning Journal:

undershirt sales drop 40 percent

Sales drop 50% according to this article found in the August 14, 1949 edition of the Pittsburgh Post Gazette:

undershirt sales drop 50 percent

Sales drop 73% in eight months according to this very specific article found in the March 18, 1955 edition of the Cumberland Evening Times:

undershirt sales drop 73 percent

Sales drop a whopping 80% according to this article found in the April 19, 1956 edition of the Alton Democrat:

undershirt sales drop 80 percent

The modern version was summarized in the March 6, 2008 edition of Time:

undershirt sales drop 75 percent

At least they mention that the legend has never been verified. The closest we come to verification in the earlier clips is the first one, attributing a 40% drop in sales to unnamed “B.V.D. executives.”

Snopes.com took on the legend but was unable to prove it as myth. They correctly wonder that if any such drop in undershirt sales actually took place, how it could possibly be attributed directly to Gable and It Happened One Night. It can’t.

They explain that Gable’s undershirt is an “example of how easily a piece of information can become an accepted ‘fact’ whose validity is never questioned despite any real evidence that it is indeed true.”

Those who spread the fact cannot prove it. Those who disagree cannot disprove it. This is how conspiracy theories are born. Both sides can only offer evidence though they usually only offer supporting evidence.

My own digging leads me to believe Clark Gable had no measurable effect on the undergarment industry. I can’t prove that because nobody saw fit to properly defend the allegation one way or the other before it became fact by decree. But I can accumulate evidence, which is what now follows.

First this tongue-in-cheek clipping from July 1934, published just five months after It Happened One Night was released, presents itself as not only the earliest, but the best, origin to our story:

Clark Gable vs King Cotton

Found in the Lowell Sun via the New York Post, July 24, 1934, page 24

The Daily News-Record that they refer to was actually a specialty publication within the textile industry:

1920 ad for advertising in the Daily News Record

But if this is the origin to the Clark Gable undershirt myth you’ll notice it doesn’t include any statistics. It doesn’t even say sales have dropped. It says that the industry is “alarmed” and that “this frets the trade,” and it says so with a bit of mirth as I read it. Maybe the industry source was alarmed, but the journalist who put the piece together for publication sure wasn’t.

Towards the end of the Snopes.com article another issue is mentioned that may have been more responsible than Clark Gable for any pain caused in the undergarment industry: The Great Depression.

In September 1934 there was a textile workers strike that lasted 22 days. “The shortage of piece goods, due to strikes, has seriously affected the underwear business,” said the New York Times in their issue dated September 24, 1934.

Also in 1934 there was a voluntary cotton-adjustment program and the Bankhead Cotton Control Act, which was passed in April of that year. The U.S. government was trying to raise the price of cotton and it cut the supply in doing so.

The disappearance of the undershirt is never reported in the business columns, just on the entertainment pages. The main concern of the Underwear Institute (yes, there was such a thing) in 1935 was the projected surge in women’s underwear sales which had sputtered five years earlier.

While I could not discover any specific document detailing sales of men’s undershirts (could this be the magic document?), it’s worth noting that general spending trends were way down by 1934-1935, when Gable’s lack of undershirt also would have wreaked it’s greatest havoc upon the industry:

Click to enlarge to full size. Use your browser's back button to return to this page.

Click to enlarge to full size. Use your browser’s back button to return to this page.

That graphic is from the Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to 1970. Note the column numbered 426 for Men and Boys Clothing. While there is an uptick in business each year from 1934 through 1937, there is a drop from 1931 to ‘34 and an even more dramatic drop from 1929, the year the Stock Market crashed and all the misery started to unfold.

It Happened One Night was a gift to Depression-era audiences. But if Clark Gable’s bare chest had sparked a trend then, barring that single 1934 article shown above, the media didn’t immediately pick up on the craze. No representative of the garment industry, from the Underwear Institute on down, felt any need to publicly place blame on Gable, nor even express general concern about the demise of the undershirt after that first bit of worry from the Daily News Record was published in ’34.

While there was occasional mention of Gable’s bare chest causing industry upheaval in the movie gossip columns of the late 1930s a Lantern search covering the the popular fan magazines and trade journals of the day doesn’t spot the trend. In fact, it doesn’t spot a mention until decades after the fact. A search of the New York Times archives for Clark Gable and undergarment calls up these results:

ny-times-archive-search-clark-gable-undergarments-130824

While the Times had covered the “Clark Gable style” since 1934, you can see that that style didn’t include mention of an undershirt until 1938. That 1938 result is the first one to pop up in the Times archives if you substitute the word undershirt for undergarment in your search.

In 1938 Hal Hode, an assistant to Harry Cohn at Columbia, the company that had produced It Happened One Night, spoke at the advertising and marketing forum of the Advertising Club:

Sales of undershirts hurt by It Happened One Night

Found in the Meriden Daily Journal, July 11, 1938, page 5.

At least Hode seems reasonable in claiming that the undershirt industry only lost thousands of dollars. Thousands of dollars would be a blip, even in the thirties. He also adds a bit of It Happened One Night legend providing a positive push for the bus industry that didn’t catch on as well as the undershirt gimmick. Finally, note that Lost Horizon was also a Columbia film and realize where Mr. Hode’s loyalties lie.

A year later, in 1939, the first edition of America at the Movies by Margaret Farrand Thorp was published. I can’t be sure of the wording in that first edition, but by the 1970 edition it was: “The story has been told so often that it must be true that the fashion of going without undershirts began when Clark Gable undressed in the tourist camp in It Happened One Night” (117).

Clark Gable 1936 Godfrey Phillips Tobacco CardIn Iris Barry’s 1939 review of the original edition of Thorp’s book for The Saturday Review she remarks that “it is amusing to hear that if Clark Gable appears without an undershirt, the manufacturers and garment workers are driven to protest for fear that millions of people might do likewise and go undershirtless.”

The wording of Barry’s 1939 take on Thorp seems to jibe best with the 1934 article that originated from the New York Post. In any case, the references began picking up steam and credence after Hode’s speech and Thorp’s book. Hode’s percentage grew with the passing years with the later mentions taking on the air of fact.

For those wishing to positively confirm that Clark Gable killed undershirts my research points to two potential sources, neither of which I could lay hands on: Profits of Underwear Manufacturers, 1918-1942 (those near Boston or Chicago may want to try to locate a rare copy); or, a direct reference from the Daily News Record, especially one coming between February 1934, when It Happened One Night was released, and September 1934, when the textile trade publication was mentioned by the Post.

Good luck!

I believe the undershirt industry probably was hard hit in 1934. Just like many other industries during the Great Depression. It appears that cotton goods in general, including undergarments or underwear such as undershirts, may have been especially hurt at the end of 1934 into 1935 by the Textile Workers Strike and New Deal farming legislation. I don’t believe Clark Gable or It Happened One Night had anything to do with it, at least until Hal Hode said so in 1938. Margaret Thorp picked up the idea and carried it into film circles.

I could be wrong. But I feel more confident about those thoughts than I do the varying and unattributed statistics appearing in many of the press clippings included on this page.

August 8, 1934, Ruston Daily Leader. They just heard that somewhere.

August 8, 1934, Ruston Daily Leader. They just heard that somewhere.

I’m too late to tell you to enjoy Clark Gable on TCM today–that day has passed–but be sure to check out what other film bloggers are talking about at the Summer Under the Stars Blogathon at Sittin’ On a Backyard Fence and ScribeHard on Film.

Visit the Summer Under the Stars Blogathon for more Clark Gable posts

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Share on Tumblr

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Filed Under: News - Notes Tagged With: Clark Gable, it happened one night, suts 2013, TCM, Turner Classic Movies, undershirts

← Odds and Ends: Wallace Beery Under the Stars With More to Come Glenda Farrell TCM Summer Under the Stars Picto-Sked →

About Cliff

I write about old movies and movie stars from the 1920s to the 1950s. I also sell movie cards, still photos and other ephemera. Immortal Ephemera connects the stories with the collectibles. Read More…



Ways to Help Support the Site:

Every little bit helps pay the bills. My thanks in advance if you'd consider helping out through one of the following methods:
 

Preferred: Shop the Immortal Ephemera Store and get yourself some vintage movie items for your trouble!

Donate direct through my PayPal.me link.

Or begin your regularly scheduled Amazon shopping through my Amazon affiliate link.

Thanks again!
—Cliff Aliperti

Comments

  1. Jan Ostrom says

    August 26, 2013 at 11:14 am

    Hi, I think that then, and now, men don’t get how much women love Clark Gable, and what a unique man and star he was. Most wives back then bought their husband’s underwear, and while few husbands were Gable, the wives could dream, couldn’t they? No one has ever equaled him. I believe the myth, statistics don’t mean a hill o’ beans.

    Loading...
    Reply
    • Cliff Aliperti says

      August 26, 2013 at 11:43 am

      Hi Jan,

      Thanks for the comment. I think we get the Gable phenomenon for the most part. He’s the biggest star of them all because the men think as highly of him as the women. Women wanted men to emulate Gable? I don’t have a problem with that, heck, I’d be willing to give it a shot!

      Personally, I’m a big fan of the guy whether or not he had anything to do with the evolution of underwear.

      Good point about the wives buying the underwear, though if they did stop buying I can’t find anybody saying so until a good four years after the movie came out. And those initial claims seem mild when compared to what they developed into over time.

      The statistics are the myth … at least until someone can source them.

      Thanks again, Cliff

      Loading...
      Reply
      • JanO says

        August 26, 2013 at 3:04 pm

        Hi Cliff, Not to belabor it, but keep in mind that people don’t rush out and stop buying stuff. The husband is told to stop wearing it, and then in a while, the company realizes not as many wives are buying them any more. The old shirts would have been worn (or not) until they were rags (Depression) or used as rags, which would take a few years to catch up to the “cause.” Oh what a theory 🙂
        I love your stuff, thanks for such good writing on interesting subjects!
        Jan

        Loading...
        Reply
        • Cliff Aliperti says

          August 27, 2013 at 7:37 am

          Thanks, Jan, glad you liked it. I was going to write about a Gable movie, but TCM wasn’t airing the few I had targeted, so I went a different way with this!

          You make another good point. The problem is, with something like this that neither of us can prove, we can each come up with plenty of good points.

          My first thought in response to you was, yes, but look at that chart up above that shows the general drop in men’s clothing sales since 1929. If everything was falling off like that, surely men’s undershirts were too, especially since they would be one of the most disposable forms of clothing. I can live without an undershirt, but I sure need need a functional pair of pants, pair of shoes, etc. My second thought was that possibly this was all a big gimmick from the undergarment manufacturers to shift sales towards the more modern form of t-shirt by later in the decade–that one’s a bit further out there granted.

          I know we could both go on and probably each think up a doozie of an idea daily for awhile!

          What I believe really happened is towards the bottom of the post. That first article (the 1934 one from the Post) is true. I think that the folks at the Daily News Record (the textile industry magazine) saw the movie and got a little scared, especially since sales were probably already taking a hit during the Depression. Then I think the problem went away until Hal Hode’s speech and that it grew from there retroactively into legend.

          Unfortunately I can’t prove that without concrete numbers specifically showing year-to-year men’s undershirt sales! That’s an obscure to non-existent number. It’s also the only number that could really prove the ‘Gable killed undershirts’ line too because I think it’s obvious that all of the other numbers are made up later.

          My favorite is the ‘business fell 73 percent in 8 months’ line. That’s an example of how statistics can be dangerous. It sounds so believable! But if it were true, why wouldn’t everyone be quoting it? After all, it’s a perfect number to make the point with and an even more extreme one than the 40-50% numbers others were using!

          Thanks again for your interest in this post. It’s a fun topic whether we agree or not!

          Cliff

          Loading...
          Reply
  2. Raquel says

    August 26, 2013 at 12:22 pm

    Excellent! I have always been curious about this story and I love how you took the time and effort to research it so thoroughly.

    Loading...
    Reply
    • Cliff Aliperti says

      August 27, 2013 at 7:41 am

      Thanks, Raquel, so glad you got a kick out of it! As I mentioned to Jan up above I don’t think we can really be sure one way or another without some pretty obscure or even non-existent numbers. But that’s what makes this fun. And I sure know what I think!

      Loading...
      Reply
  3. silverscreenings says

    August 28, 2013 at 8:11 pm

    WHO KNEW?! This is a great story…and would make an interesting film too, no?

    Loading...
    Reply
    • Cliff Aliperti says

      September 1, 2013 at 12:44 pm

      Glad you enjoyed it!

      Loading...
      Reply
  4. Jill says

    September 20, 2013 at 1:31 am

    Cliff–

    This has always been one of my favorite Hollywood legends. I absolutely loved this piece. Thanks for taking the time to research this. Completely fascinating.

    Loading...
    Reply
    • Cliff Aliperti says

      September 20, 2013 at 3:23 pm

      Jill, I probably had more fun writing this than anything else during Summer Under the Stars month … even if I got a bit obsessive about it! Heck, that’s the fun part. Glad you enjoyed it. Such a mundane topic at first glance, but we all love this kind of stuff!

      Loading...
      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. 2013 tcm SUTS Blogathon Day 25: Clark Gable | ScribeHard On Film says:
    August 26, 2013 at 11:13 am

    […] And Cliff from Immortal Ephemera discusses Gable and his inadvertent take-down of the undershirt industry. […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  2. Day 25: Clark Gable | Sittin on a Backyard Fence says:
    August 30, 2013 at 2:32 am

    […] Cliff from Immortal Ephemera discusses Gable and his inadvertent take-down of the undershirt industry. […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  3. How Historic Research Works: Clark Gable’s Undershirt | Sarah's Notebook says:
    November 11, 2013 at 10:47 pm

    […] https://immortalephemera.com/42243/did-clark-gable-kill-the-undershirt/ […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  4. Clark Gable’s Undershirt–or Lack Thereof | History Myths Debunked says:
    November 16, 2013 at 6:29 pm

    […] https://immortalephemera.com/42243/did-clark-gable-kill-the-undershirt/ […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  5. TCM Picks of the Week | Memoirs of a Mangy Loner says:
    February 17, 2014 at 6:24 am

    […] https://immortalephemera.com/42243/did-clark-gable-kill-the-undershirt/ […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  6. Undershirt | illustrated fashion alphabet says:
    April 17, 2014 at 5:05 pm

    […] of the 20th century, and apart from a supposed fall from grace in 1934 thanks to Clark Gable (more about that here), the undershirt remained a must have garment for men throughout much of the 20th century. Cotton […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  7. The fourth decade of cinema (1925 – 1935) – A•STAR says:
    March 8, 2016 at 8:20 pm

    […] for bed he takes off his shirt to reveal he’s bare-chested. The American undershirt industry apparently spiralled into decline when millions of American men gasped, “Why do I wear an undershirt if Clark Gable […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  8. Do You Even Lift? – awaywithjay says:
    November 20, 2016 at 12:33 pm

    […] it has definitely evolved in the last century. Compare a picture of John Wayne from 1936 or Clark Gable from 1934 to Chris Evans and Chris Pratt in Captain America (2011) and Guardians of the Galaxy (2014) […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  9. Cold Weather Style: Winter Clothes for Men - Tailor & Barber: A Men's Style, Fashion, Grooming and Lifestyle Blog says:
    January 22, 2019 at 6:02 am

    […] One word above all others sticks in my head when I think about winter clothes for men: wool. Wool suits, wool coats, wool sweaters, wool socks. The only things I keep cotton are my shirts and my underwear, and the shirts are usually heavier weaves like oxford, herringbone, and twill. You would be surprised by the difference a thicker shirt can make. And if I need a little extra warmth, I’ll throw on an undershirt, even though I don’t usually wear one. Thanks a lot, Clark Gable. […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  10. Clark Gable – Gentleman of Style says:
    December 9, 2020 at 11:50 am

    […] fact true but rather than to bore you with the details of this urban legend, I suggest you read on here if you would like to learn more about this […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  11. Even Voldemort Masks Up in New Public Service Announcement – iftttwall says:
    February 11, 2021 at 10:12 am

    […] This sort of alleged influence has a long history, including tales of Clark Gable singlehandedly destroying undershirt sales in Depression America and Fonzie from Happy Days generating a 500 percent increase in library card […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  12. Even Voldemort Masks Up in New Public Service Announcement – Reason.com – All Sides Now says:
    February 11, 2021 at 10:18 am

    […] This sort of alleged influence has a long history, including tales of Clark Gable singlehandedly destroying undershirt sales in Depression America and Fonzie from Happy Days generating a 500 percent increase in library card […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  13. Even Voldemort Masks Up in New Public Service Announcement - Indeki - Real News Network says:
    February 11, 2021 at 10:24 am

    […] This sort of alleged influence has a long history, including tales of Clark Gable singlehandedly destroying undershirt sales in Depression America and Fonzie from Happy Days generating a 500 percent increase in library card […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  14. Even Voldemort Masks Up in New Public Service Announcement – Reason.com says:
    February 11, 2021 at 11:09 am

    […] This sort of alleged influence has a long history, including tales of Clark Gable singlehandedly destroying undershirt sales in Depression America and Fonzie from Happy Days generating a 500 percent increase in library card […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  15. It Happened One Night & The Roots of the Rom-Com | Cultured Vultures says:
    June 9, 2021 at 7:00 am

    […] Clark Gable is shown alone with his female co-star, almost unthinkable for 1934. Within the year, it was purported that undershirt sales in the United States declined 40 to 50 percent; it is even rumored that Gable’s character served as inspiration for Bugs Bunny. However, the […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  16. The Surprising Way It Happened One Night Inspired Bugs Bunny - Khabarhd says:
    December 27, 2021 at 12:19 pm

    […] been substantiated, but a popular rumor about “It Happened One Night” was that sales of men’s undershirts plummeted after Gable undressed for millions of […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  17. The Surprising Way It Happened One Night Inspired Bugs Bunny | Fishstream TV says:
    December 27, 2021 at 1:38 pm

    […] been substantiated, but a popular rumor about “It Happened One Night” was that sales of men’s undershirts plummeted after Gable undressed for millions of […]

    Loading...
    Reply
  18. cara menggunakan bibit parfum laundry says:
    July 5, 2023 at 3:35 pm

    cara menggunakan bibit parfum laundry

    Did Clark Gable Kill the Undershirt? — Immortal Ephemera

    Loading...
    Reply
  19. does ferragamo repair belts says:
    December 24, 2023 at 11:01 pm

    does ferragamo repair belts

    Did Clark Gable Kill the Undershirt? — Immortal Ephemera

    Loading...
    Reply

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Copyright © 2002-2025 Immortal Ephemera - (privacy policy) - Article by Cliff Aliperti unless otherwise noted.

%d